Buckeye candies: peanut butter balls dipped in dark chocolate coating with a circle of peanut butter showing on top

Buckeyes

Peanut butter balls dipped in Merckens Cocoa Dark coating, with a circle of peanut butter left showing on top. You need no oven and no mold, and one batch makes about 28. Keep them in the refrigerator.

Makes
About 28 buckeyes
Hands-on time
About 45 minutes
Ready in
About 2 hours 10 minutes
Keeps
About 1 week in the refrigerator

Get the supplies Go to the recipe

Get the supplies

Tick what you need and untick anything you already have. Each tick adds one regular pack at its normal price.

Merckens Cocoa Dark Confectionery Coating Wafers - 1 lb

Coats the peanut butter balls. About 9 oz goes on them; the rest keeps the coating deep enough to dip in.

In stock

$9.50

Good to have

Parchment Paper 12-1/8” x 16-3/8”- Half Sheet (approx 46 shts-1/2 #)

Half-sheet parchment paper to line the pan. About 46 sheets.

In stock

$6.25
Gold Foil Mini Cupcake Liner (Approx. 42 Pieces)

One buckeye in each cup for a tray or a box. One pack holds a full batch.

In stock

$3.35
Gold Candy Box, 1/4 lb. Clear lid

Gift box with a clear lid. It holds ¼ lb, which is about four buckeyes by weight.

In stock

$3.50
4 oz Paramount Flakes

Thins coating that melts too thick. A little goes a long way.

In stock

$5.95

From the grocery store and your kitchen

Gloria's does not sell the first five. Buy them at a grocery store.

  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter (a regular kind, not a natural kind that separates)
  • ¼ cup (½ stick) butter
  • 2 cups powdered sugar, and a little more in case the dough is sticky
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • Toothpicks
  • A mixing bowl and a spoon or a hand mixer
  • A small, deep microwave-safe bowl to melt the coating in, completely dry
  • A baking sheet that fits in your refrigerator

Buckeyes

Makes: About 28 buckeyesHands-on time: About 45 minutesReady in: About 2 hours 10 minutes

Ingredients

  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • ¼ cup (½ stick) butter, softened
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 cups powdered sugar, plus more if needed
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 16 oz Merckens Cocoa Dark coating wafers (one 1 lb bag)

Tools

A mixing bowl, a baking sheet lined with parchment paper, toothpicks and a small, deep, dry microwave-safe bowl.

Why a full pound of coating? Each ball is dipped about three-quarters of the way, so the coating must be deep. About 9 oz goes on the buckeyes. If the rest has no peanut butter or crumbs in it, let it set, keep it in a sealed bag and melt it again another day.

Use a regular creamy peanut butter. A natural peanut butter, the kind with oil on top, separates and makes oily centers.

Method

  1. Mix the centers

    Beat the peanut butter, butter and vanilla together until smooth. Add the powdered sugar and salt, and mix slowly until combined. The dough should be soft but not sticky, like play dough.

    If the dough sticks to your fingers, mix in more powdered sugar, 1 tablespoon at a time.

  2. Roll the balls

    Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Roll the dough into balls of about 1 tablespoon each, about 1 in. across, and set them on the sheet. You should get about 28.

  3. Chill the centers

    Cover the sheet loosely and put it in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour, until the balls are firm.

    Firm, cold centers stay on the toothpick and do not soften in the coating.

  4. Melt the coating

    Microwave the wafers in the small, deep bowl for 30 seconds on medium-high power, then stir. Continue in bursts of 15 to 30 seconds, and stir after each one, until the coating is smooth. Do not let it go above 120°F.

    Let the coating cool until it is only just warm, about 100°F, before you use it.

    The wafers keep their shape until you stir them, so stir before you decide to heat again.

  5. Dip each ball on a toothpick

    Take a few balls at a time out of the refrigerator, and leave the rest to stay cold. Push a toothpick about halfway into the top of a ball. Dip the ball into the coating until about three-quarters of it is covered. Leave a circle of peanut butter showing at the top.

    As the coating gets low, tilt the bowl so that it stays deep enough to dip.

  6. Let the extra drip off

    Lift the ball out and hold it over the bowl. Turn it slowly until the coating stops dripping. Set it on the lined sheet with the toothpick still in it.

    A thin, even coat sets smooth and does not form a flat pool around the base.

  7. Chill until set

    Put the sheet in the refrigerator for about 20 minutes, until the coating is firm.

  8. Close the toothpick holes

    Twist each toothpick out. Smooth the peanut butter over the hole with a clean, dry fingertip. Put the buckeyes in an airtight container, with parchment paper between the layers, and keep them in the refrigerator.

    Keep your fingers dry. Water must not touch the coating.

To store: Keep in an airtight container in the refrigerator for about 1 week. Serve within 2 hours of taking them out.

Gloria's Cake & Candy Supplies, 11117 Washington Blvd, Culver City. www.gloriascakeandcandy.com/pages/buckeyes

If something goes wrong

The centers are soft or sticky

The dough needs more sugar, or it got warm. Mix in more powdered sugar, 1 tablespoon at a time, until the dough no longer sticks. Chill the balls until they are firm, and take only a few out of the refrigerator at a time.

The centers are oily

Natural peanut butter, the kind that separates, makes oily centers. Use a regular creamy peanut butter. Warm hands also bring oil out of the dough. If the dough looks oily, chill it for about 15 minutes and then roll again.

The ball falls off the toothpick

The center was too soft, or it warmed while you dipped it. Put the ball back in the refrigerator until it is firm. Push the toothpick in about halfway, and dip a few balls at a time so that the rest stay cold.

The toothpick hole still shows

Twist the toothpick out after the coating has set, then smooth the peanut butter over the hole with a clean, dry fingertip. If the center has gone very cold and hard, let it stand for a few minutes first. Do not wet your finger: water must not touch the coating.

The melted coating is too thick

Wafers that are old or that took up a little moisture melt smooth but thick. Stir in paramount flakes and keep stirring until they melt in. Merckens gives ¼ oz (7 g) for each pound of coating. If the coating is still too thick, add the same amount again.

Do not add water, milk, butter or ordinary food coloring. They make the coating thicker.

If the coating is grainy or stiff because water got into it, or because it went above 120°F, flakes may not save it. Start again with fresh wafers.

How to store it

Keep the buckeyes in an airtight container in the refrigerator, with parchment paper between the layers. They stay good for about 1 week.

To serve them, take out only as many as you need. They may stand out for up to 2 hours, or 1 hour if the room is above 90°F. Keep the lid on while they come to room temperature, so that water forms on the container and not on the coating.

Do not put them in the freezer. The coating can crack or turn dull when it thaws.

Wrap it as a gift

Set each buckeye in a gold foil mini cup for a tray or a box. A ¼ lb gold candy box with a clear lid holds about four.

Tell the person to keep them in the refrigerator.

Ways to change it

Milk chocolate buckeyes

Use Merckens Cocoa Lite in place of Cocoa Dark for a sweeter, milk chocolate taste.

Fully dipped peanut butter balls

Drop each ball into the coating and turn it with a fork until it is covered. Lift it out on the fork and tap off the extra. Top it with Christmas tree quins or carnival mix sprinkles while the coating is wet.

White stripes

When the coating has set, melt a handful of Merckens White wafers. Dip a fork in the coating and wave it quickly over the dark part of each buckeye.

Team colors

Dip the balls in colored Merckens wafers in place of Cocoa Dark. We stock red, orange, blue and dark green.

Questions people ask

Why are they called buckeyes?

With a circle of peanut butter showing, they look like the nut of the Ohio buckeye tree, the state tree of Ohio. The candy only takes its name from the nut. The real nut is poisonous, so do not eat it.

Do buckeyes need to be refrigerated?

Yes, keep them in the refrigerator. The centers contain butter, and they hold their shape better when cold. For serving, they may stand out for up to 2 hours, or 1 hour if the room is above 90°F.

Can I use chocolate chips instead of coating wafers?

You can, but the result is less predictable. Chocolate chips are real chocolate. Unless real chocolate is tempered, it can set dull or streaky, and it softens more easily in a warm room.

Merckens coating wafers are made to melt and set without tempering, so they are the easier choice here.

Do I need a thermometer?

No, but it helps. Without one, heat the coating in short bursts, stir each time, and stop as soon as the last wafers melt. The coating must never feel hot. Then wait until it feels only slightly warm before you use it.

With a thermometer, melt the coating to between 115°F and 120°F, and use it at about 100°F.

How do I get the supplies?

Tick the supplies on this page and add them to your cart. Choose pickup at 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City; orders are usually ready within 24 hours and we email you when yours is ready. We also ship.

You can also buy everything in the shop. See our hours.

What about allergies?

Buckeyes contain peanuts, and butter contains milk. Read the ingredient label on every pack before you make them for someone with a food allergy. A label does not always say when a product is made on equipment that also handles nuts, milk or wheat. If you are not sure, ask the manufacturer.

Stuck? Ask us.

Gloria's has helped Los Angeles bakers and candy makers since 1972. Call the shop on (323) 289-8807, or bring your question to 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City. We are normally open Tuesday to Saturday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Check this week's hours and get directions

More to make

See all recipes