An open white bakery box with a window, packed with stacks of decorated Christmas cookies in clear bags tied with red twist ties

Cookie gift box

How to pack homemade cookies in a box with a window so they arrive whole and fresh. You bag the cookies in stacks, lay them flat and fill the gaps so nothing moves. One 10 × 7 in. box holds about 2 dozen cookies 3 in. across.

Makes
About one box of 2 dozen cookies
Hands-on time
About 20 minutes
Ready in
About 20 minutes, once the cookies are cool and dry
Keeps
About 1 week at room temperature

Get the supplies Go to the recipe

Get the supplies

Tick what you need and untick anything you already have. Each tick adds one regular pack at its normal price.

White Window Strawberry Box 10"x7"x2.5"

The box. It holds about 24 cookies 3 in. across, in six stacks of four.

In stock

$3.25
3.5 x 2.25 x 8.25 in. 1 lb Cello Bags (50 count)

One bag for each stack of about four cookies. One box uses 6 of the 50 bags.

In stock

$9.99
Red Twist Ties (25 Ct)

Closes each bag. One box uses 6 ties.

In stock

$1.90
Parchment Paper 12-1/8” x 16-3/8”- Half Sheet (approx 46 shts-1/2 #)

Lines the box and, crumpled, fills the gaps. One box uses about 2 sheets of the 46.

In stock

$6.25

Good to have

Gold Foil Mini Cupcake Liner (Approx. 42 Pieces)

Holds small cookies or candy in the corners and keeps them apart.

In stock

$3.35
10X10X2.5 in. White W/Window Pie Box

A larger 10 × 10 in. window box. It holds about 36 cookies 3 in. across.

In stock

$1.95
9X9X2.5 in. White W/Window Cake Box

A 9 × 9 in. window box. It holds about 16 cookies 3 in. across, or 36 small ones.

In stock

$1.55
Christmas Cookie Bag 5 pc - 3.94”x3.94”

A small Christmas bag, about 4 in. square, for one cookie as a single gift.

In stock

$1.99
Gold Twist Ties (25 Ct)

Gold ties, if you prefer gold to red.

In stock

$1.95

From your kitchen

  • About 24 homemade cookies, completely cool, and dry if they are iced
  • Scissors
  • A pen and a small card for a note
  • To mail the box: a sturdy shipping carton at least 14 × 11 × 7 in., bubble wrap or other padding, and packing tape

Cookie gift box

Makes: About one box of 2 dozen cookiesHands-on time: About 20 minutesReady in: About 20 minutes, once the cookies are cool and dry

What you need

  • About 24 cookies, about 3 in. across, cool and dry
  • 1 white window box, 10 × 7 × 2.5 in.
  • 6 clear cello bags, 1 lb size
  • 6 twist ties
  • 2 sheets of parchment paper
  • Gold foil mini cups, for small cookies or candy (optional)

Tools

Scissors, and a sturdy shipping carton with padding if you plan to mail the box.

The count is an estimate. Six stacks of four cookies 3 in. across fit the 10 × 7 in. box in two rows of three, with a little room for padding. Bigger cookies fit fewer, and smaller cookies fit more.

A box is best for one kind of cookie, or for several kinds with the same texture. Each kind goes in its own bag.

How to pack the box

  1. Choose cookies that travel well

    Firm, flat cookies travel best. Cut-out sugar cookies with dry royal icing, shortbread, firm drop cookies and bar cookies all work well. Leave out delicate cookies that break easily, and anything that must be kept in the refrigerator, such as cream cheese bars.

  2. Make sure the cookies are cool and dry

    Pack cookies only when they are completely cool. Royal icing must dry for at least 8 hours, or overnight, before you stack or bag the cookies. If the icing is still soft, it will smudge and the cookies will stick together.

    Dry royal icing is hard and matte all the way across.

  3. Keep crisp and soft cookies apart

    Crisp cookies take up moisture from soft cookies and go soft. Soft cookies dry out. Pack crisp and soft cookies in separate boxes. Put strong flavors, such as peppermint or ginger, in their own bags so the other cookies do not taste of them.

  4. Bag the cookies in stacks

    Make stacks of about four cookies of the same size and kind. Put a small square of parchment between iced cookies. Slide each stack into a cello bag, press out the air and close the bag tightly with a twist tie. Fold the top of the bag under the stack.

  5. Line the box

    Fold the box into shape. Cut a sheet of parchment paper to fit the bottom and lay it in. Crumple the second sheet into loose balls for padding.

  6. Fill the box

    Lay the bagged stacks flat in two rows of three. Put the heaviest cookies at the bottom of any stack and the prettiest cookies on top, under the window. Set small cookies or candy in gold mini cups in any corners.

  7. Fill the gaps and close

    Push crumpled parchment into the gaps so the stacks cannot slide. Close the lid. Tilt the box gently. If anything moves, open it and add more paper. Do not press so hard that the cookies break.

    Nothing should shift when you tilt the box.

  8. Add a note

    Write what is in the box, the day you baked it and any allergens, such as wheat, milk, egg or nuts. Tape the note to the lid or tuck it inside.

To store: With each stack sealed in its own bag, the cookies are best eaten within about 1 week. Keep the box at room temperature.

Gloria's Cake & Candy Supplies, 11117 Washington Blvd, Culver City. www.gloriascakeandcandy.com/pages/cookie-gift-box

If something goes wrong

The cookies broke on the way

They had room to slide, or the box was not padded enough. Fill every gap with crumpled parchment until nothing moves when you tilt the box. Bag the cookies in stacks so that each stack moves as one piece. If you mail the box, pack it inside a carton with padding on every side.

The iced cookies stuck together or smudged

The icing was not completely dry. Let royal icing dry for at least 8 hours, or overnight, before you stack or bag it. Put parchment between iced cookies in each stack.

The crisp cookies went soft

They were packed with soft cookies, or the bags were not closed tightly. Pack crisp and soft cookies in separate boxes, and twist each bag tightly closed.

All the cookies taste of peppermint

Strong flavors spread to other cookies. Seal strong-flavored cookies in their own bag, or give them their own box.

The box was crushed in the mail

A bakery box is not strong enough to mail on its own. Put it inside a sturdy shipping carton with about 2 in. of padding on every side.

Keeping the box fresh

Keep the box at cool room temperature, out of the sun and away from heat. With each stack sealed in its own bag, the cookies are best eaten within about 1 week. Plain cookies kept airtight stay good for about that long. Cookies with dry royal icing can keep longer, up to about 2 weeks.

Do not refrigerate the box. Moisture can soften the cookies and the icing.

To get ahead, freeze plain baked cookies for up to about 1 month in an airtight container. Thaw them in the closed container at room temperature before you decorate or pack them.

Mailing a cookie box

Pack the bakery box as described, then put it inside a sturdy shipping carton. Leave about 2 in. of room on every side and fill that space with bubble wrap or other padding. For the 10 × 7 × 2.5 in. box, that means a carton of at least 14 × 11 × 7 in. Tape the carton closed and mark it Fragile and Perishable.

Mail it early in the week so that it does not sit in a post office over a weekend. If time is short, choose a faster service. Do not mail cookies that need the refrigerator.

Ways to change it

A bigger box

A 10 × 10 × 2.5 in. window box holds nine stacks of four cookies 3 in. across, in three rows of three. That is about 36 cookies, or 1½ batches of our cut-out cookies.

Small cookies in a square box

Cut the cookies with a 2½ in. fluted cutter and pack nine stacks of four in a 9 × 9 × 2.5 in. window box. That is about 36 small cookies.

One cookie as a gift

Put one dry, decorated cookie in a Christmas cookie bag and close it with a gold twist tie. This works well for teachers, neighbors and party favors.

Cookies and candy

Pack the cookies on one side and set pieces of peppermint bark in gold foil mini cups on the other. Seal the bark in its own cello bag first, because peppermint flavors other cookies.

Questions people ask

How many cookies fit in the box?

About 24 cookies 3 in. across fit the 10 × 7 × 2.5 in. box, in six stacks of four. This is an estimate. Thick or large cookies fit fewer. If a stack sits higher than the box, take a cookie off each stack.

How far ahead can I pack it?

Pack it on the day you give it, or the day before. Iced cookies need one full night to dry first. With each stack sealed in its own bag, the cookies are best eaten within about 1 week.

Can I use a cookie tin instead?

Yes. A tin is strong, so it is a good choice for mailing. Bag the cookies the same way and fill the gaps with crumpled parchment so nothing moves.

Which cookies should I not put in a gift box?

Anything that must be kept cold, such as cookies with cream cheese filling or frosting. Also leave out very delicate cookies that break when you touch them, and cookies with icing that is still soft.

How do I get the supplies?

Tick the supplies on this page and add them to your cart. Choose pickup at 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City; orders are usually ready within 24 hours and we email you when yours is ready. We also ship.

You can also buy everything in the shop. See our hours.

What about allergies?

Homemade cookies usually contain wheat, milk and egg, and some contain nuts. Write the allergens on the note in the box. Read the label on every pack you used, including sugars and sprinkles. A label does not always say when a product is made on equipment that also handles nuts, milk or wheat. If you are not sure, ask the manufacturer.

Stuck? Ask us.

Gloria's has helped Los Angeles bakers and candy makers since 1972. Call the shop on (323) 289-8807, or bring your question to 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City. We are normally open Tuesday to Saturday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Check this week's hours and get directions

More to make

See all recipes