Christmas tree and star sugar cookies covered in smooth red, green and white royal icing, some with sanding sugar and tree sprinkles

Decorated Christmas cookies

Cut-out sugar cookies covered in smooth red, green and white royal icing, with sanding sugar or Christmas quins on top. You outline each cookie, fill it with thinner icing and let it dry overnight. One batch of icing covers about 24 cookies 3 in. across.

Makes
About 24 decorated cookies
Hands-on time
About 1½ hours
Ready in
About 10 hours, including drying overnight
Keeps
About 2 weeks in an airtight container

Get the supplies Go to the recipe

Get the supplies

Tick what you need and untick anything you already have. Each tick adds one regular pack at its normal price.

4 oz Meringue Powder

Makes the icing set hard. One batch uses 3 tablespoons, so the 4 oz pack makes about 3 batches.

In stock

$8.95
AmeriColor Super Red Soft Gel Paste Food Color - .75 oz

Colors the red icing. Add it with a toothpick. One small bottle is plenty for a batch.

In stock

$3.95
Leaf Green Gel Paste Food Color .75 oz

Colors the green icing for the trees. Add it with a toothpick.

In stock

$3.95
12" Disposable Pastry Piping Bag

You need 6: one for each color and thickness. Ticking this adds 1, so change the quantity to 6 in your cart.

In stock

$0.60
Xmas Trees Sprinkle Quins

Tiny Christmas trees to press into wet icing. A pinch is enough for each cookie.

In stock

$2.99

Good to have

Cookie Scribe

A fine point to push icing into corners and pop air bubbles. A toothpick also works.

In stock

$1.00
8 oz White Sanding Sugar

Sparkling white sugar to cover wet icing on stars and snowflakes.

In stock

$7.95
Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract (4 fl oz)

Flavors the icing without turning it yellow. The batch uses ½ teaspoon.

In stock

$7.99
8 oz Meringue Powder

For more cookies. The 8 oz pack makes about 7 batches of icing.

In stock

$17.50
White Window Strawberry Box 10"x7"x2.5"

A white box with a window. Holds about 24 dry, decorated 3 in. cookies in stacks.

In stock

$3.25

From the grocery store and your kitchen

Gloria's does not sell the first two. Make the cookies first, and buy the powdered sugar at a grocery store.

  • About 24 baked cut-out sugar cookies, 3 in. across, cooled completely
  • 4 cups (1 lb) powdered sugar
  • A stand mixer or a hand mixer, with a bowl that has no trace of grease
  • A sieve, to sift the sugar
  • Small bowls, spoons and a butter knife
  • Toothpicks
  • Plastic wrap and damp paper towels
  • Scissors, and tall glasses to hold the filled bags
  • A small fan, if your kitchen is humid

Decorated Christmas cookies

Makes: About 24 decorated cookiesHands-on time: About 1½ hoursReady in: About 10 hours, including drying overnight

Ingredients

  • 3 tablespoons meringue powder
  • 6 tablespoons warm water
  • 4 cups (1 lb) powdered sugar, sifted
  • ½ teaspoon clear vanilla (optional)
  • Red and green gel paste food color
  • Christmas tree quins or white sanding sugar, to finish
  • About 24 cut-out sugar cookies, 3 in. across

Tools

A mixer, small bowls, six disposable piping bags, scissors, toothpicks or a cookie scribe, and plastic wrap.

This is the short version of our royal icing recipe, which explains each icing thickness in more detail.

One batch makes about 3 cups of icing. That covers about 24 cookies 3 in. across, with a little under 2 tablespoons on each. For larger cookies, make a second batch.

Method

  1. Make the icing

    Wipe the bowl and beaters with a paper towel so there is no trace of grease. Whisk the meringue powder and warm water until frothy. Add the sifted powdered sugar and the vanilla. Beat until the icing is thick and glossy and holds a stiff peak, about 7 to 10 minutes with a stand mixer or 10 to 12 minutes with a hand mixer.

    Grease stops royal icing from setting, so the bowl must be completely clean.

  2. Keep some back, then color

    Put about ½ cup of the stiff white icing in a small bowl and press plastic wrap onto its surface. You use it later to thicken icing that is too thin. Divide the rest into three bowls: white, red and green. Dip a clean toothpick in the gel color, stir it into the icing, and repeat until you have the color you want.

    Red and green get darker as they stand. Color them a little lighter than you want, or make them the day before.

  3. Thin for outlining and flooding

    Put about one-third of each color in a separate bowl for outlines. Stir in a few drops of water, about ⅛ teaspoon for each cup, until the icing is like toothpaste: it pipes a smooth line that holds its shape and does not spread. Flood icing is thinner. Thin the rest of each color for flooding: start with about 1 teaspoon of water for each cup, then add ½ teaspoon at a time, until a line drawn through the icing with a knife fills in completely in about 10 seconds.

    Stir gently, in a figure eight. Fast stirring adds air bubbles.

  4. Fill the bags and let them rest

    Cover the bowls and let the icing stand for at least 10 minutes, so air bubbles can rise. Spoon each icing into its own bag. Stand each bag in a tall glass. Snip a very small hole in the outline bags and a slightly larger hole in the flood bags. Start small, because you can always cut more.

    Keep the bowls covered with plastic wrap or a damp paper towel. Royal icing crusts quickly in the air.

  5. Outline every cookie

    Pipe a line of outline icing just inside the edge of each cookie. Hold the bag tip a little above the cookie and let the line fall into place. Outline all the cookies first. Let the outlines stand for about 10 to 15 minutes, until they are no longer shiny.

    The outline is a wall that holds the flood icing in.

  6. Flood the centers

    Fill inside each outline with flood icing of the same color. Use the cookie scribe or a toothpick to push the icing into the corners and up to the outline. Tap the cookie gently on the counter to bring air bubbles to the top, and pop them with the scribe right away.

    Fill the outline fully. A thin layer can sink as it dries.

  7. Add sugar or quins while the icing is wet

    Work on one cookie at a time, as soon as you flood it. Press Christmas tree quins gently into the wet icing. For a sugar finish, hold the cookie over a plate, spoon white sanding sugar over the wet icing to cover it, then tip the cookie and tap it gently so the extra falls onto the plate.

    Toppings stick only while the icing is wet and shiny.

  8. Let them dry overnight

    Leave the cookies flat and uncovered in a cool, dry room for at least 8 hours, or overnight. Do not stack them, bag them or pipe on top until the icing is hard all the way through. In a humid room, set a fan on low near the cookies, not pointing straight at them.

    Dry icing is hard and matte. If it gives when you press it lightly, wait longer.

To store: When the icing is completely dry, keep the cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for about 2 weeks. Do not refrigerate them.

Gloria's Cake & Candy Supplies, 11117 Washington Blvd, Culver City. www.gloriascakeandcandy.com/pages/decorated-christmas-cookies

If something goes wrong

The colors ran into each other

Dark colors such as red can bleed into white, mostly when the icing dries slowly or the room is humid. Let one color dry for at least 2 hours before you flood the color next to it. A fan on low helps the icing dry faster.

Icing that is too thin also dries slowly. Thicken it with a spoonful of the stiff icing you kept back. Red mixed the day before bleeds less.

Small dips or craters formed as the icing dried

This happens most often in small areas, such as a dot or a narrow strip, and in icing with a lot of air beaten into it. Use outline icing, not flood icing, to fill very small areas. Fill each area fully, and dry the cookies near a fan on low.

Do not beat the icing for longer than it needs.

There are bubbles or tiny holes in the icing

Air got into the icing when it was stirred. Let thinned icing stand, covered, for at least 10 minutes before you fill the bags. After you flood a cookie, tap it on the counter and pop any bubbles with a scribe or toothpick right away, before the surface sets.

The icing is still soft the next day

Grease in the bowl, a humid room, or icing that was not beaten long enough can stop royal icing from setting. Dry the cookies near a fan on low. Next time, wipe the bowl and beaters clean before you start and beat the icing until it holds a stiff peak.

The flood icing ran over the edge of the cookie

The flood icing was too thin, or there was a gap in the outline. Stir a spoonful of the stiff icing you kept back into the flood icing. Check that each outline is closed before you flood.

How to store it

Let the icing dry completely, at least 8 hours and better overnight. Then layer the cookies in an airtight container with parchment paper between the layers, or seal them in cello bags. Keep them at cool room temperature, out of the sun. They stay good for about 2 weeks.

Do not refrigerate decorated cookies. They do not keep well there, because moisture can soften the icing.

Leftover icing keeps for up to about 2 weeks in an airtight container at room temperature with plastic wrap pressed onto its surface. Stir it well, and add a few drops of water if it needs it, before you use it again.

Wrap it as a gift

When the icing is completely dry, about 24 cookies 3 in. across fit a 10 × 7 × 2.5 in. white window box. See how to pack a cookie gift box so the cookies arrive whole.

For a single cookie, use a Christmas cookie bag and close it with a red twist tie.

Ways to change it

Snowy white stars

Flood stars in white and cover them with white sanding sugar while the icing is wet.

Gold stars

Flood stars in white or red and press gold star quins into the wet icing, or cover them with gold sanding sugar.

Candy cane colors

Flood the cookies in white and scatter candy cane quins over the wet icing.

Brighter white

Stir a little bright white gel color into the white icing so it looks whiter next to the red and green.

Snowmen and snowflakes

Cut the cookies with a snowman or snowflake cutter. Large cookies need more icing, so make a second batch for 24 large cookies.

Questions people ask

Can I use a royal icing mix instead?

Yes. Make the royal icing mix as the pack directs. Then thin it, color it and use it the same way as the icing on this page.

How far ahead can I decorate?

Ice the cookies within about 2 days of baking them. When the icing is completely dry, the cookies keep for about 2 weeks in an airtight container at room temperature. Allow one full night for drying before you pack or give them.

Can I freeze decorated cookies?

Some decorators freeze them, but results vary. Try one cookie first. Wrap the cookies tightly, put them in an airtight container and freeze them for up to about 6 weeks. Thaw them at room temperature in the closed container before you open it.

Why use meringue powder and not egg whites?

Meringue powder gives more even results from batch to batch than fresh egg whites, which vary in size. It also means no raw egg white goes into the icing. Our royal icing recipe also has an egg white version.

How do I get the supplies?

Tick the supplies on this page and add them to your cart. Choose pickup at 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City; orders are usually ready within 24 hours and we email you when yours is ready. We also ship.

You can also buy everything in the shop. See our hours.

What about allergies?

The cookies contain wheat, milk and egg. Read the label on the meringue powder, colors, sugars and quins for egg and other allergens before you make these for someone with a food allergy. A label does not always say when a product is made on equipment that also handles nuts, milk or wheat. If you are not sure, ask the manufacturer.

Stuck? Ask us.

Gloria's has helped Los Angeles bakers and candy makers since 1972. Call the shop on (323) 289-8807, or bring your question to 11117 Washington Blvd in Culver City. We are normally open Tuesday to Saturday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Check this week's hours and get directions

More to make

See all recipes